“Christmas Day has come and gone, the New Year lies ahead. Strange things happen Between the Years, in the days outside of time. Minutes go wild, hours vanish. Idleness becomes a clever thief, stealing the names of the days of the week, muting the steady tick of watches and clocks. These are the hours when angels, ghosts, demons and meddlers ride howling wind and flickering candlelight, keen to stir unguarded hearts and restless minds.” Ami McKay, Half Spent was the Night: A Witches’ Yuletide
It is fitting to be posting about this book now as it is set in the “dead days” between Christmas and New Year’s Eve. If you have read McKay’s novels The Virgin Cure or Witches of New York, then you will already be familiar with the three witches, Adelaide, Eleanor and Beatrice. The novella is a bit of a Christmas ghost story that includes divinations, a mysterious Baroness, a New Year’s ball, a demon and some “ghosts” from the witches’ past that they would rather forget. The story is charming and full of fun touches like recipes that McKay includes of her characters’ Christmas dishes. I like how McKay is able to create an atmosphere that is both cozy and mysterious at times. There are a lot of beautiful details in this story (not to mention that the book itself is gorgeous – I am a sucker for fancy end papers).
I read The Virgin Cure but Witches of New York is still hanging out in my TRP and I wish I had read it first. There are a lot of references to the witches’ backstories from the other novels and I think the story would be more meaningful if I had more understanding of those events. Someone told me (after I read Half Spent was the Night) that the novella finishes a lot of plot developments that McKay started in Witches so I guess that’s what I get for jumping ahead. For me, the plot moved too fast, especially when it came to the events of the ball. It felt like McKay was trying to wrap up several story lines as quickly as she could and I would have preferred a longer book to give the story a chance to develop a little further. Especially as the plot reached it’s climax, it felt like the clock struck midnight, the story ended and I was thinking, “that’s it? But I wanted more!” The character of the baroness is really interesting and I would have loved to see McKay develop her story further.
If you are a fan of McKay’s writing, I think you will like this book. It has all the richness you associate with her novels and evokes that feeling of hearing stories around the fire on a winter’s night. Let me know your thoughts if you read it!

