Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows by Balli Kaur Jaswal: A Review

“The pages didn’t really matter. The women could retell them. There were recordings. What Nikki wanted to do was talk to Kulwinder. Explain how these stories came about. Compel her to see that these women who had started one quiet rebellion could come together to fight a bigger injustice.” – Balli Kaur Jaswal, Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows

I have to confess right from the start that this novel really surprised me. Based on what I had heard, I was expecting something light and fun and while it definitely is fun and funny, it also digs into some pretty weighty issues. Set in the Punjabi community in Southall, a part of London, the main character, Nikki, accepts a job teaching Punjabi widows to read and write. Or at least, that is what she is told to do by her conservative boss, Kulwinder. The widows have other ideas. Rather than learning to read and write, they want to tell stories … erotic stories. (Like the kind of erotic stories that will make you blush if you are reading them in public.) What I hadn’t realized before reading this book is that in the Sikh community, if a man dies, his widow is never supposed to remarry. For the women in the writing group, the erotic stories were a way of recapturing a part of their lives that was gone forever, or of attempting to live out fantasies that their marriages had never provided.

The story reveals a lot of the ways the inhabitants of Southall are supported and constricted by their community. Nikki is the daughter of Indian immigrants to England. She is caught between her parents’ culture and that of the London she grew up in. She wants to be a “modern” girl, living apart from her parents, avoiding arranged marriage and choosing a career for herself, but after quitting law school and the death of her father, Nikki is adrift. She sees teaching the writing class as a way to make a difference for the women in her community being oppressed by traditional gender roles. The way the story unfolds juxtaposes notions of modern and traditional, East and West, and the roles of women and men in the community. Jaswal does an excellent job of creating women who feel real – they are kind and generous and backbiting and petty – and as a result, the reader greatly empathizes with their problems. The roles duty and honour play in the Sikh community are closely examined as they are often used to hold the community together and hide its sins. Far from being just chick-lit or a rom com,  Jaswal uses the erotic story-writing group as a means of exploring so much about Southall’s Punjabi community in a way that is both fond and critical. One thing that dawned on  me only after I read the novel is despite their circumstances, every single female character in this novel is strong. The novel also includes a subplot surrounding the mysterious death of Kulwinder’s daughter that keeps you turning the pages. There is a little bit of everything for readers here: romance, mystery, family drama and coming-of-age.

This is an excellent novel. I love books that allow you a glimpse into the lives of people in a way your real life would never let you experience and Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows definitely ticks that box. Jaswal surrounds all the issues she confronts in the book with great storytelling. It’s funny and thought-provoking and ultimately uplifting so I guess what I’m saying is, you really should read it. If you do, let me know what you think. Until next time, happy reading!

 

February Line Up

Since it’s February, the theme this month will be “love” in honor of Valentine’s Day but before you go breaking out the Harlequins, you should know that I am not exactly a roses and chocolates kind of gal so I tried to choose books that would avoid all the cliched bodice ripping and come at the theme in unique ways.

February 9, 2019: An American Marriage by Tayari Jones

This book appeared on just about every “best of 2018” list I came across. Set in contemporary Atlanta, it is the story of newlyweds Celestial and Roy. While their marriage is troubled from the beginning, they seem passionately in love. Then Roy is convicted of a crime he didn’t commit and sent to prison. After five years, Roy’s sentence is overturned and he is free but when he returns, it is uncertain whether Celestial still considers herself his wife. Her career as an artist has taken off and she is in a relationship with her childhood best friend, Andre. When Roy arrives on her doorstep a free man, Celestial is left to choose between continuing to build a life with Andre, or trying to save her marriage.

February 16, 2019: Erotic Stories for Punjabi Widows by Balli Kaur Jaswal

This novel is about a group of women who join a writing class in London’s Punjabi community. The main character, Nikki, realizes that her students, mostly Sikh widows, have a wealth of memories and fantasies to share and their little community begins to express their creativity and secrets within the confines of the class. But a group called the Brothers threatens to expose their scandalous stories in reaction to what they see as the failings of the women’s morality. The book speaks to the power of women’s communities and stories while remaining heart-warming and funny.

February 23, 2019: The Power by Naomi Alderman

This is another book that made a lot of “best of” lists when it was published in 2016. The Power is a little nod to those of you who might be looking for something a little anti-Valentine’s to read this February. It was recommended to me by a couple of friends who said they couldn’t get through it fast enough. Set in a world that seems like ours, a new force emerges  – women and teenage girls have suddenly developed incredible strength and they can cause pain or even death with only the slightest effort. With this one change, everything we recognize shifts drastically. I find speculative fiction like this interesting because in inventing a new world, it often provokes questions about our own.

So here they are, the February reads for 2019 and not a Danielle Steele to be seen. If you are planning to read any of these, or have already beat me to them, I would love to hear your thoughts. Until next time, happy reading!